Membership

末日聖徒イエス・キリスト教会の信者のただのもう一人で、個人的に意見を風に当てつつです。
I am just another member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints airing my personal opinions.
This "hands-on" is in the form of what we call a personal testimony.
この「ハンズオン」は、個人の証という形に作って行きます。

My personal ideas and interpretations.
個人の発想と解釈です。

I hope it's useful. If not, I hope you'll forgive me for wasting your time.
お役立つ物ならば、うれしく存じます。そうでなければ、あなたの時間を無駄に費やしてもらってしまって、申し訳ございません。

Above all, don't take my word for the things I write. Look the scriptures up yourself. Your opinion of them is far more important to you than mine.
何よりもここに書いているものそのままだと思わないでください。参考の聖句を是非調べて読んでください。私の意見よりはあなたに対して価値があるのはあなたの意見です。
Showing posts with label freedom of religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label freedom of religion. Show all posts

Friday, October 11, 2024

... Let Them Worship How, Where or What They May

In the Articles of Fatih of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is this:

11 We claim the privilege of worshiping Almighty God according to the dictates of our own conscience, and allow all men the same privilege, let them worship how, where, or what they may.

We are serious about this.

The fashions and vicissitudes and culture wars, etc. of human culture have altered, in the common context, the meanings of every meaningful word in the above, but we are still dead serious about this.

I have tried to invent a new way to talk about this, without using the words that have, in the vicissitudes of history, become offensive to many, where I substitute the word "cosmology" for "religion", and such, but it only moves the goalposts, and does not lead to mutual understanding. 

And mutual understanding is my real goal, to somehow invite you and your friends, and your enemies, to consider that we argue about it more about abstract definitions than substance -- arguing about choice of dictionaries, in effect.

Even the phrase, "article of faith":

Article: 

Of the definitions in the dictionaries, the one that probably came to mind when you read this word is 

written composition on a news or magazine site

or such.

But what we mean is closer to 

clause

-- particularly a clause of belief or faith rather than a clause of law. 

Speaking of faith,

Faith: 

The popularized definition of faith refers to religious belief, and has even been pushed towards 

system of superstition, and choice of favorite comic book or movie series or other mythologies and their heroes

But what we mean is closer to

fundamental beliefs and how those beliefs affect behavior and thinking and lives

-- but if we are not careful, even there, we can fall into the false trap of the false dichotomy between faith and works.(It's not just a Christian thing, or even "just a religious thing", that false dichotomy.)

For example, if you claim to be an atheist or agnostic, that is an assertion of one of your core beliefs and how it affects your thinking and behavior. 

Or, if you prefer not to be accused of believing something, or anything at all, you still have a choice in your approach to understanding. Or even whether you choose to approach understanding.

And we want to allow you that choice.

Sometimes it is even a valid choice to suspend the choice to understand, rather than to choose to claim understanding. And we want to allow you even that choice when you feel a need to. 

Heaven knows we have found that, at times, we have had to suspend understanding in order to let God teach us something we couldn't understand before.

Freedom of Religion is not about freedom of choice of favorite superheroes. Or, it is not just about that.

I mean, if you choose a favorite superhero, you are often using that as a metaphor to talk about something deeper about what you believe or what you understand, or what you want to understand, or something else important to you.

That's what freedom of religion was meant to be when the framers of the Constitution of the United States of America wrote the First Amendment to it -- the freedom to take your own approach to life, to the extent that it's possible to do so.

...

:::

:::

... and if this were to go viral, it would be only a matter of moments before the popular meanings of the phrase "take your own approach" were changed to something I do not intend, and, to the extent that such changes in idiom result from people's attempts to understand, I guess I have to allow that, too.



Tuesday, August 15, 2023

Which God among the N-thousand?

It's a common question when discussing the reality of God --

Joe: Which God, of which religion? There are thousands of religions.

Bob: Uhh,

Joe: There are so many. Why is the Mormon God the only true God?

Jean: Well, for one thing, there is no Mormon God. The Book of Mormon teaches about Jesus Christ, His Father, and the Holy Ghost. We are Christian.

Joe: Then why the Christian God? What's wrong with, for instance, the Japanese or Greek Gods? 

Carrie: Every religion feels just as strongly about their God.

Bob: Can I quote one of our Articles of Faith?

Joe: Why?

Bob: It just might help.

Carrie: I guess I don't mind.

Joe: Will it explain why the Mormon God is the one true God?

Jean: Number Eleven?

Bob: That's the one I have in mind.

Jean: It's definitely relevant. 

Joe: Okay, if you insist, let's hear it.

Bob: It goes like this:

We claim the privilege of worshiping Almighty God according to the dictates of our own conscience, and allow all men the same privilege, let them worship how, where, or what they may.

Joe: I don't get it. All that says is that you want to worship the God of your own invention.

Jean: I think you missed the last clause.

... let them worship how, where, or what they may.

Carrie: You don't mean that. 

Bob: No?

Carrie: You don't. Millie was telling me all about how all the other religions are wrong and just leading everyone to hell.

Jean: Unfortunately, some members of our Church don't seem to mean it, or don't seem to understand it.

Carrie: Millie said she wasn't sure you, in particular, understood God.

Bob: Unfortunately, some of our members are particularly unwilling to apply this to fellow members of the same Church. 

Jean: But this is an Article of Faith. It's official, published by the Church.

Let them worship how, where, or what they may.

Bob: Not limited to people who aren't members of the Church. All men. All human beings. Even in the Church. It says

We ... allow all men the same privilege, ...

Carrie: Privilege?

Jean: 

... the privilege of worshiping Almighty God according to the dictates of our own conscience ...

Bob: And it's for everyone, so -- according to their conscience, according to your conscience.

Joe: But your Almighty God.

Jean: 

... how, where, or what they may.
Carrie: "Almighty God". That's your God.

Bob: You'd rather worship a weak God?

Jean: It's a description.

Carrie: Maybe I would prefer a weak God, that wouldn't be always sending me to hell. 

Jean: That's not what God does.

Joe: And you say there is only one God.

Carrie: Why do you send all those missionaries out?

Bob: There is only one God, but there are thousands of ways to view that God.

Jean: More like billions. One for every person on the planet.

Bob: And considering that our understandings evolve, I guess, more than billions.

Jean: Every one of us. It's what we do most of our lives.

Bob: It's probably the most human thing we do.

Carrie: What's the most human thing we do?

Bob: Try to understand God.

Jean: Try to figure out what our own highest priorities should be. 

Joe: What does figuring out priorities have to do with God?

Carrie: Isn't it bad enough you're trying to tell us we have to worship the God you made up? And now you're talking about priorities?

Bob: A person's set of priorities is what that person thinks is most important, right?

Carrie: Well, yeah. You don't get to tell me what I should think is most important.

Bob: Right. That's not my business.

Jean: ... let them worship how, where, or what they may. It's your job to set your own priorities.

Bob: You have to choose what's important to you, what is, in effect, the God that rules your life.

Joe: I ain't letting no God run my life.

Jean: But you choose what you think is important.

Joe: Damn sure.

Bob: Of course. What we're saying is that asserting all people's privilege of following their own conscience, as individuals, is the same thing as asserting all people's privilege of worshiping the God of their own choice. And that's the same thing as asserting the privilege that we all have of setting our own priorities, of choosing what's most important to us.

Joe: Then why do you have to call it God?

Bob: Because what you believe about how you and the world around were created, and about who is running things, is probably the biggest factor in how you set your priorities.

Jean: Although what you think is important also depends a lot on how you think you and the world came to be, and who is in charge.

Joe: Pretty soon, you're going to be saying the same thing Millie says, that evolution is my religion.

Jean: Isn't it a big part of what you have instead of religion?

Carrie: I don't have anything instead of religion.

Bob: Don't you have a philosophy about life?

Joe: Sure, but that's not a religion. I don't believe in any God.

Bob: There are religions that do not claim a God, you know.

Carrie: Such as?

Jean: Most branches of Buddhism claim not to have a God.

Joe: That's different.

Jean: Yes it is. But it's also the same. There was somebody in Japan that told me the short piece of really thick rope over his door was his Shintō Kami -- his God. It showed him how to be persistent.  

Carrie: And you told him that would lead him to hell, right?

Jean: No, I thought it seemed like a good metaphor and a good ideal, and I told him so.

Joe: But calling it God?

Jean: I felt an impression that it was his high priority, and Shintō allows changing Kami, changing priorities.

Bob: And when we claim the privilege of worshiping according to our own consciences, we also claim that everyone who doesn't call it worshiping or God or religion has the right to claim their own philosophies and priorities and stuff, according to what they believe is right.

Jean: I don't trust you. You send out missionaries.

Bob: I think the biggest failures of our missionary program is when a missionary hasn't figured out that each person has to follow his or her own conscience, I mean, ...

Carrie: His or her, I heard that. Pronouns are important!

Bob: So is grammar. It's hard for me to mix plural and singular forms without getting confused, and the only true neutrals for people in English are plurals. You're changing the subject.

Carrie: My privilege. I don't want to talk about this any more.

Jean: Okay, let's talk about something else. 

Joe: But why do you send missionaries out?

Jean: Well, our missionaries are supposed to be inviting people. 

Bob: And why do certain people publish books and lecture about how their version of God doesn't exist? People like to share what they think.

Joe: But it's irrational!

Jean: Humans are all a little crazy. It's okay. Sharing what we think about helps us all keep sane.